I thought this book was good. It was as good as if not slightly better than the previous 2 books (definately book 2 at any rate), simply because i think it was more eventful and exciting. I felt more gripped and interested in what was going on, and it was a nice change of pace for this book to be set in Idris rather than New York. There were some more surprise twists, including one or two I'd hoped for since book 1 because I thought it was a silly plot device. Overall though, a good and entertaining book.